Preachers, Migrants, and Islamic Hadith Metaphors.
The elements of dogs, water, and sex workers (“dirty women”) are frequently used by Islamic scholars in Southeast Asia when debating compassion toward marginalized groups, including migrants. • The Hadith Metaphor: Preachers often cite the famous prophetic narration (Hadith) about a prostitute (often colloquially framed in sermons as a “sinful or dirty woman”) who found a thirsty dog panting near a well. Out of pure mercy, she drew water using her shoe to save the dog’s life, and because of this single act of compassion toward a ritually unclean animal, God forgave all her sins.
• Application to Migrants: Progressive Islamic advocates and preachers in Malaysia (such as those speaking at the New Muslims Community Conference) routinely invoke these specific traditions. They use them to challenge xenophobia, arguing that if God granted salvation to a marginalized woman for showing mercy to a stray dog, Muslims have a profound moral obligation to show basic human dignity and compassion to vulnerable human beings, such as undocumented migrants and refugees.
The Rakyat Post
A Malaysian Islamic preacher has urged his own community to extend the same compassion they show oppressed Muslims abroad to Rohingya refugees living in Malaysia.
Firdaus Wong Wai Hung, president of Multiracial Reverted Muslims (MRM), made the remarks at the New Muslim Community Conference, where he urged Malaysians not to strip Rohingya refugees of their humanity.
“Even prisoners of war have their rights. You should provide them with food,” he said, noting that stateless status does not extinguish a person’s fundamental dignity.
Wong drew a direct line between the dehumanisation of Rohingya refugees in Malaysia and historical atrocities — including the Nazi treatment of Jews and the ongoing situation in Palestine — and asked why Malaysian Muslims, who are vocal about injustice overseas, apply a different standard to refugees living among them.
Maimunah Muhammad
I have to agree with the words told by Mr. Firdaus. He is reminding muslim to mind what you said and how you said it.
We can disagree with an act of a person/collective race (Rohinyan) who some have cross their boundaries in our nation but as muslim, we must still keep intact our iman.
Comment with good truthful words. State the fact but do not use harsh and demeaning words and label the whole race like some dirty rags/garbage.
At the end of the day, those actions will only bring stain to our nation and especially religion of Islam in Malaysia.
Mr. Firdaus never said to force anyone to shelter all rohingyan in our own home BUT to never demonise a human being. Even Firaun was given a chance by Allah to repent through His Messenger because Allah is mercy. And even Nabi Musa came to Firaun bearing only facts and truth without mocking Firaun.
As a human being, we have no right to deem a person and dehumanise a person over their race and the act of some people in the group . That is not the true akhlah of Islam.
Amigo Nathan
·
Compassion should never depend on race, religion or nationality. If we stand against oppression overseas, we should also show fairness and humanity to those living among us. At the same time, compassion must go hand in hand with respect for Malaysian laws, security and the rights of local communities.
